A federal judge ruled Wednesday (Jan. 31) that a tribute band sued by Earth, Wind & Fire for trademark infringement can continue to try to prove its bold counterargument: That the legendary R&B group abandoned the intellectual property rights to its name.

Faced with a lawsuit for using the name “Earth Wind & Fire Legacy Reunion” at concerts, the smaller act argued last summer that the original group had allowed plenty of other tribute bands to use its name without repercussion — so many, in fact, that it could no longer claim any exclusive legal rights to it.

Lawyers for Earth, Wind & Fire have called that argument meritless and demanded that it be dismissed, but in a decision Wednesday, Judge Federico A. Moreno refused to do so. Though he said Legacy Reunion might ultimately find it “difficult” to prove that “abandonment” argument, he said they had “done enough” to avoid having it tossed out entirely in the early stages of the case.

Earth, Wind & Fire has continued to tour since founder Maurice White died in 2016, led by longtime members Philip Bailey, Ralph Johnson and White’s brother, Verdine White. The band operates under a license from an entity called Earth Wind & Fire IP, a holding company owned by Maurice White’s sons that formally owns the name.

In a March lawsuit, that company accused Legacy Reunion of trying to trick consumers into thinking it was the real Earth Wind & Fire. Though it called itself a “Reunion,” the lawsuit said the tribute band contained only a few “side musicians” who briefly played with Earth, Wind & Fire many years ago.

“Defendants did this to benefit from the commercial magnetism and immense goodwill the public has for plaintiff’s ‘Earth, Wind & Fire’ marks and logos, thereby misleading consumers and selling more tickets at higher prices,” the group’s lawyers wrote.

Tribute acts — groups that exclusively cover the music of a particular band — are legally allowed to operate, and they often adopt names that allude to the original. But they must be clear that they are a tribute band, and they can get into legal hot water if they make it appear that they are affiliated with or endorsed by the original. In 2021, ABBA filed a similar case against a what it called a “parasitic” band called ABBA Mania.

Facing the lawsuit filed by Earth, Wind & Fire, Legacy Reunion filed a response in August that listed out a dozen other tribute acts that allegedly feature “Earth, Wind & Fire” as part of their name. Legacy Reunion argued that since the original band had “taken no action to enforce its purported trademark rights,” it had legally abandoned them.

“Due to the unchecked third-party use of the phrase, [EW&F] has abandoned ‘Earth, Wind & Fire,’ and [the name] has lost its trademark significance,” wrote attorneys for Substantial Music Group, which operates Legacy Reunion.

In a response fired back in September, attorneys for Earth, Wind & Fire said the band had very obviously not abandoned its rights to the name, adding that the “bare allegations” made by Legacy Reunion, combined with just a “handful” of other tribute bands, falls “woefully short” of what they would need to prove.

Wednesday’s decision by Moreno rejected Earth, Wind & Fire’s motion to dismiss the abandonment argument, but it does not mean that Legacy Reunion has evaded the band’s infringement allegations. To the contrary, the smaller group must now actually prove that argument in future proceedings.

An attorney for the Earth, Wind & Fire did not immediately return a request for comment.



Source link

By fcjyy

FREE MONOPOLY G FREE Playstatio Amazon Gift Car IMVU - Redeem y Free Coins & Fr BIGO LIVE DIAMO FREE PSN Gift C TOP 5 APPS THAT Free Instagram FREE MONOPOLY G Free Fire Diamo FREE PAYPAL MON How To Get Free IMVU Free Credi PUBG MOBILE FRE PUBG FREE UC 10 ONLYFANS PREMIU (Free) Shein Ca REAL* Free!! Ti 8 Ball Pool Fre Free Tiktok Coi Bigo Live Diamo Free Free TIKTO UNVEILING THE B New Real Credit FREE ONLYFANS P Free Instagram ONLYFANS VIEWER how to get unli PUBG FREE BP AN Bingo Blitz fre How To Get Unli IMVU - Redeem y ONLYFANS ACCOUN [1000K+Free] Sh IMVU - Redeem y Free Playstatio How to get Free Today's Bingo B Bingo Blitz Fre TOP 5 APPS THAT unlimited free Free Instagram 8 Ball Pool Fre DIGITAL WALLETS COIN MASTER LAT Free Fire Diamo 2 BEST STORIES Get Free $750 S free coins on t Get Unlimited F FREE UNLIMITED FREE COIN MASTE 90% OFF - FREE DUKE JONES DETO Earn FREE Credi Bingo Blitz Fre How to Get Free SECRET UC TRICK Instant Bingo b DIGITAL WALLETS google play red Free Monopoly G HOW TO GET FREE GET FREE AMAZON FREE COIN MASTE bigo live free Free Instagram FREE AMAZON GIF Bigo Live Free ONLYFANS HACK U REAL* Free!! Ti Free Playstatio BIGO LIVE unlim MAKING AN AI ON HOW TO GET FREE FREE PAYPAL 25 DIGITAL WALLETS Advent Calendar Free Diamonds F PDF EARN FREE P How To Get Free Bingo Blitz Fre PlayStation Gif ONLYFANS ACCOUN free google pla BIGO LIVE unlim 13 Ways to Get 2024 TIERRAMISU Amazon Gift Car Monopoly GO ! F Monopoly GO Fre COIN MASTER FRE New Free Amazon Free Free TIKTO Free Fire Diamo How to get ANYT SHEIN GIFT CARD [500$] Free PSN FREE TIKTOK COI Bigo Live Diamo COIN MASTER FRE Bingo blitz Fre 8 Ball Pool Fre Free Coins & Fr Free fire new F Free PSN Gift C PlayStation Gif Generate Unlimi Free Diamond Fr How to Get Free PUBG MOBILE UC How to get FREE FREE MONOPOLY G Coin Master Fre How to Get Free BIGO LIVE Free how to get unli How to Get Free HOW TO GET A FR [UPDATED] MONOP FREE Instagram HOW TO EARN PAY connect % 8 Way NEW MATHOD FREE COIN MASTER FRE 10 Easy Ways To MONOPOLY GO FRE Amazon Gift Car Free SHEIN Gift ONLYFANS VIEWER Instant Bingo b Free Instagram Generate Unlimi Bingo Blitz Gif How I Get Monop Free Instagram FREE Instagram Free Instagram Earn Free IMVU Amazon Gift Car UNVEILING THE B 90% OFF - FREE Shein Free Unli Free Instagram Bingo Blitz Fre Amazon Gift Car COIN MASTER ALL MONOPOLY GO FRE How To Get Free TÉLÉCHARGEMENT free IMVU Credi